Glossary entry (derived from question below)
Hebrew term or phrase:
te'udat dargat yitzug
English translation:
temporary rank certificate
Added to glossary by
Suzan Chin
Mar 5, 2004 04:21
20 yrs ago
Hebrew term
te'udat dargat yitzug - תעודת דרגת יצוג
Hebrew to English
Other
Military / Defense
What is תעודת דרגת יצוג in English?
It appears to be a military certificate in which a "turai" is receiving a "dargat yitzug" of "sagam".
Thanks!
It appears to be a military certificate in which a "turai" is receiving a "dargat yitzug" of "sagam".
Thanks!
Proposed translations
(English)
5 +1 | Pro tem / temporary rank certificate | Eynat |
5 +3 | (Interim) Representative Rank Promotion | Raphy ELDAD |
5 | brevet certificate | judithyf |
5 -3 | Army Promotion Certificate | Alex Zelkind (X) |
3 -1 | local rank cerificate | Jonathan Spector |
Proposed translations
+1
5 hrs
Selected
Pro tem / temporary rank certificate
I am no longer sure about 'interim', because in the typical case, the holder never does go to officer school and therefore does not proceed to a permanent rank. Therefore, it's not 'interim' (which is more like 'beynayim') but rather 'pro tem' (zmanit).
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 09:50:51 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
Alex says above that \'there is no mention that it\'s temporary\'. Of course there is: it\'s all there in the word YITZUG, meaning that it\'s a special rank for REPRESENTATION purposes only, and the holder will eventually REVERT to the old rank when the special reason no longer applies. You need to understand the concept behind the term to be able to translate it: you don\'t translate the words verbatim. And to do that, you need to understand the cultural connotations, the context in which the term is embedded. Saying \'There is no such thing because I say so\', when you have never experienced the contextual circumstances, is a childish tantrum and not the way a professional translator behaves. As to telling Suzan she is \'pathetic\', a \'mere civilian\', and best of all - \'everyone wants to show how smart (s)he is\'; all I can do is refer you to pots and kettels.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 09:51:45 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
kettles.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 09:56:03 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
kettles.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 13:29:43 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
These ranks are mainly used for personnel representing Israel abroad, of course.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 09:50:51 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
Alex says above that \'there is no mention that it\'s temporary\'. Of course there is: it\'s all there in the word YITZUG, meaning that it\'s a special rank for REPRESENTATION purposes only, and the holder will eventually REVERT to the old rank when the special reason no longer applies. You need to understand the concept behind the term to be able to translate it: you don\'t translate the words verbatim. And to do that, you need to understand the cultural connotations, the context in which the term is embedded. Saying \'There is no such thing because I say so\', when you have never experienced the contextual circumstances, is a childish tantrum and not the way a professional translator behaves. As to telling Suzan she is \'pathetic\', a \'mere civilian\', and best of all - \'everyone wants to show how smart (s)he is\'; all I can do is refer you to pots and kettels.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 09:51:45 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
kettles.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 09:56:03 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
kettles.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 13:29:43 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
These ranks are mainly used for personnel representing Israel abroad, of course.
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
Comment: "Thank you so much, Eynat and everyone else who have responded to my question.
Ta, Suzan :)"
-3
20 mins
Army Promotion Certificate
http://citationexpress.com/Cert_Army Promotion Certificate.h...
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 05:34:27 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
What do you exactly want then? I\'m telling you what it is called in the US Army where I was an officer. You won\'t get anything else - this is what it is called. There are no \"temporary\" promotion certificates. A soldier receives a certificate of promotion. When he will be promoted later - his old certificate will be automaticaly revoked. Same thing will happen if he will be demoted in rank.
Privates, PV2, PFC receive promotion on basis of time served. They move up in the ranks every 6 months.
Why do you want to make it difficult?
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 06:09:41 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
There are some simple and basic things which don\'t even require explanation. Do what you want. I should not have answered your question in the first place. Instead of at least receiving a simple \"thank you\" - some absurdity begins where everyone wants to show how smart (s)he is. Children don\'t act that way.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 05:34:27 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
What do you exactly want then? I\'m telling you what it is called in the US Army where I was an officer. You won\'t get anything else - this is what it is called. There are no \"temporary\" promotion certificates. A soldier receives a certificate of promotion. When he will be promoted later - his old certificate will be automaticaly revoked. Same thing will happen if he will be demoted in rank.
Privates, PV2, PFC receive promotion on basis of time served. They move up in the ranks every 6 months.
Why do you want to make it difficult?
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2004-03-05 06:09:41 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
There are some simple and basic things which don\'t even require explanation. Do what you want. I should not have answered your question in the first place. Instead of at least receiving a simple \"thank you\" - some absurdity begins where everyone wants to show how smart (s)he is. Children don\'t act that way.
Peer comment(s):
agree |
00000000 (X)
1 min
|
Thank you, Esther
|
|
disagree |
Jonathan Spector
: You clearly misunderstood the term.
59 mins
|
What part of it did I misunderstood?
|
|
disagree |
Eynat
: Errr ... there IS a temporary promotion. Have you served in the IDF? I have. Were you an IDF corporal who had to sit on IAF HQ committees where the others were officers and were given a temporary 2nd Lt rank? I have.
4 hrs
|
OK-OK. First it's a certificate (and there is no mention that it's temporary), then all of a sudden it becomes a temporary " ID card". I don't play such games :) Anyway, this system of temporary promotion to officer' position is bizarre and makes no sense
|
|
disagree |
Sue Goldian
: For the reasons stated by Jonathan and Eynat
4 hrs
|
Jonathan did not state any reasons, and Eynat... Well, you and Eynat, and Suzan... Nevermind :)
|
|
disagree |
Iris Bat-Or
: Acting Rank - a rank given for a specific duty (or a tour of duty) in and out of Israel, mostly for appearance sake.
7 days
|
-1
1 hr
Hebrew term (edited):
te'udat dargat yitzug - ���� �� ���
local rank cerificate
Certain positions in the army carry a lieutenant's rank but the 'officer' was chosen from the civilian population (army spokesman for example). The rank applies as long as he remains in the position, reverting to his lower rank when he leaves.
Peer comment(s):
disagree |
Alex Zelkind (X)
: Doesn't say anything to the English speaking audience
3 mins
|
neutral |
Eynat
: Ignore Alex's comment: there are cultural terms that need a translator's footnote, and this may be one of them. However, it's 'temporary' rather than 'local'.
3 hrs
|
+3
2 hrs
(Interim) Representative Rank Promotion
This is usually an officer rank promotion given in special cases to military that did not graduate an officer course, yet they need an officer rank to perform their duty or special functions. It's not a permanent rank, but an interim one requiring the candidate to go through an official officer course, otherwise his rank will be removed when terminating his special function.
To acceede to such a rank, you can be a Turay or a sergeant or whatever rank lower to the one you postulate for.
To acceede to such a rank, you can be a Turay or a sergeant or whatever rank lower to the one you postulate for.
Peer comment(s):
agree |
Baruch Avidar
20 mins
|
agree |
Eynat
: Quite right (corporal, in my case).
2 hrs
|
agree |
Jonathan Spector
7 hrs
|
9 hrs
Hebrew term (edited):
te'udat dargat yitzug - ���� �� ���
brevet certificate
dargat yitzug us a brevet or local (nominal) rank in which the soldier's pay remains as was.
Peer comment(s):
neutral |
Eynat
: I thought this only applied to the American Civil War (the last ever was awarded in 1918). Thus, using the term for a modern army (IDF) would be confusing.
5 hrs
|
Discussion